|
Identifying the relative mix and proportion
of these factors in the patient, selecting the
proper procedure knowing the risk/benefit ratio,
and communicating this information to the patient
constitutes the essential ingredients of the cosmetic
consultation.
TRENDS TOWARD AMBULATORY
PROCEDURES
Along with the increasing demand for rejuvenative
procedures, a parallel trend can be seen in the
patient's desire for minimum "down time."
Busy personal and professional schedules make
many traditional cosmetic procedures beyond the
reach of many patients. The trends appear to be
strongly in favor of "the minimal" approaches:
minimal down time, minimal invasion, minimal cost.
Some of the therapies being developed and touted
are more successful at addressing these "consumer"
issues than others.
THERAPIES FOR ULTRAVIOLET
LIGHT DAMAGE
Resurfacing using chemical peel solutions of trichloroacetic
acid or carbolic acid (phenol) and mechanical
dermabrasion were the mainstays of resurfacing
for years. Laser resurfacing using the carbon
dioxide laser and Erbium lasers have given benefits
of greater precision in skin wounding but have
introduced new paradoxes: the significant morbidities
of prolonged healing periods and persistent erythema
appear to be inversely related to ultimate skin
smoothing and tightening.
Gentler forms of resurfacing under current investigation
include the use of repetitive particle peeling
using aluminum oxide crystals forced under pressure
against the skin, producing so-called "microdermabrasion."
These procedures repeated over time appear to
effect consistent changes in the epidermis associated
with photoaging (freckling, discoloration, texture,
and pore size) without significant morbidity.
Utilizing existing radiofrequency technology,
surface skin ablation (Coblation®, McGhan
Corp.) can be damage and appears to be another
modality that can address skin photoaging. A plasma
flow is created at the tip of the application
device which causes disruption of the tissue at
the molecular level without associated neighboring
tissue being affected by heat damage. This is
an example of "cross-over" technology
coming from one area of medicine to another since
it originally was developed for intra-articular
sculpting in orthopedics and was tweaked to be
applicable to skin surgery.
Other new modalities being explored at the present
time include the possibility of selective subsurface
heating of the dermis with the long wave Nd:YAG
laser at 1320 nm (CoolTouch®, New Star Laser,
Inc). This wavelength may produce collagen shrinkage
without damaging the overlyingepidermis, giving
a tightening effect without the morbidity of the
ablative lasers. The pursuit of dermal tightening
without excessive epidermal morbidity remains
the holy grail of laser therapy in facial rejuvenation.
One apparent disadvantage at present is the need
for multiple treatment sessions over time and
relatively modest improvements in comparison to
more established resurfacing techniques.
TOPICAL SKIN THERAPY
Developments in topical therapy have not been
ignored. An explosion of topical retinoid products
reached the markets in the past year. Stabilized
retinol preparations are now widely available
without prescription and appear to convey many
of the improvements seen with chronic topical
retinoic acid (Retin-A®, Ortho Pharmaceuticals)
without products. Other topical therapies new
to the anti-aging scene include plant kinins (Kinerase®,
ICN Pharmaceuticals) which appear to have both
anti-irritant and photoaging reversal properties
with no perceived irritation. These products will
be marketed directly to the consumer as moe clinical
experience is gathered.
THERAPIES FOR LOSS OF VOLUME
Aging produces a profound loss of subcutaenous
fat in the peri-oral area, the temporal fossae,
the pre-malar areas, chin and forehead. The older
face has a flattened quality to the cheekbones,
a sunken appearance to the lips,a bulging of the
inferior fat pads of the eye and, in general,
a loss of the fullness and roundness of youth..
Experiences plastic surgeons have recognized this
and are moving away from excessive fat removal
to fat repositioning or augmentation.
For example, the routine removal of the infraorbital
fat as a part of blepharoplasty, which often accentuated
the deep grooves between the lower eyelid and
the cheek , has become outdated. Now surgeons
prefer to utilize an arcus marginalis release
and mobilize the fat medially and anateriorly
to fill in that groove and return a more youthful
appearance to the lower eyelids through resotration
of fullness. Similarlly, repositioning of the
pre-malar fat has become an important part of
routine face lifting, reversing the aged appearance
that comes from flattening of the cheekbone contours.
The ultimate recognition of the importance of
the subcutaneous volume of the face comes from
the work of surgeons who have evolved techniques
of fat transfer to restore the volume contours
of the aged face. Microlipoinjection in small
and larger volumes, placed subcutaneously and
intramuscularly has been used with great success
to reshape the aging face. While difficulties
remain in the predictability and longevity of
fat transfers, the aesthetic effects are often
impressive in the naturalness of the resulting
appearance. Restoration of loss of volume lies
behind the appeal of injectable fillers such as
collagen (Zyderm®, Zyplast®, McGhan Corp.),
hyaluronic acid (Hylafor®, Biomatrix, Inc.),
cadaver tissue (Dermaologen® Collagenisis,
Inc.), cultured autologous fibroblasts (Isolagen®)
and autologous collagen (Autologen®). Bovine
collagen now has a 25-year track record and remains
the material of choice for injectable augmentation.
Cultural perceptions of risk and bovine spongiform
encephalopathy have made the material unsellable
in the U.K. So the search for newer, less antigenic
materials continues.
Newere technology now exists for production of
human recombinant collagen (Fibrogen, Inc.) which
is moving slowly toward the commercial application.
This potentially "pure" form of collagen
will likely eliminate many of the other injectable
products now on the market since it will offer
augmentation without risk of rejection or allergy,
which remain the greatest clinical problem with
injectables to date.
LIP AUGMENTATION
Lip augmentation with injectables remains one
of the most frequently sought after cosmetic procedures
performed in aesthetic medicine today. The market
is literally overflowing with new injectable agents
and alloplastic implants of expanded polyterra-fluorethylene
(SoftForm, McGhan Corp., Gore-Tex). While initially
introduced as a cosmetic tool, SoftForm shows
great promise in restroration of facial contours
in individuals afflicted with the lipodystrophy
associated with HIV disease and protease inhibitors.
SELECTIVE MUSCULAR DENERVATION
WITH BOTULINUM TOXIN
Botulinum A extotoxin (BTX-A) is a neurotoxin
produced by the anaerobic bacterium Clostridium
Botulinum. Botulinum toxin (BTX) is actually present
as seven different serotypes (A-G), but it is
BTX-A that is commercially avalable (BOTOX®,
Allerghan, Inc.) BTX-A inhibits the release of
acetylcholine from the pre-symaptic membrane of
the neuromuscular junction of striated muscle
leading to the onset (1-14 days) of muscle weakness
and paralysis. Over time (3-4 months) new neuromuscular
junctions are formed and muscle function slowly
returns. Inhibition of acetylcholine release from
sympathetic nerves innervating eccrine sweat glands
likewise produces a profound loss of sweating
in the treated area. These two sites of pharmacological
action lie behind the recent explosive increase
of the use of BTX-A in cosmetic dermatology for
hyperhidrosis and for movement associated wrinkles.
First used in monkeys by San Francisco's own Dr.
Alan Scott in 1973 - who demonstrated reversible
ocular muscle paralysis lasting three months -
BTX-A was soon reported as a successful treatment
in humans for strabismus, blepharospasm and spasmodic
torticollis. In 1986, Jean and Alastair Carruthers,
a Vancouver-based husband and wife team consisting
of an oculoplastic surgeon and a dermatologist,
identified the cosmetic use of BTX-A for movement-associated
furrows in the glabella area leading to their
seminal publication in 1992. In 1994, they reported
their experience with other movement-associated
wrinkles on the face and thus the era of cosmetic
BTX-A treatment was born.
Perhaps nothing else has driven home the impact
of facial musculature on facial aging like the
introduction of botulinum toxin for selective
chemical denervation of selected muscles of the
face. Paralysis or partial weakening of the glabellar
corrugator/procerus complex, the forehead frontalis
and the laterial orbicularis muscles has simply
revolutionized the managment of the third of the
aging face. Deep glabellar lines, which could
be only briefly improved with injectable fillers,
now melt away with the placement of botulinum
toxin in the corrugator/procerus complex. Crow's
feet lines, which routinely reappeared after deep
resurfacing, now vanish in a few days. Even the
troublesome horizontal lines and creases of the
lower eyelid, which persisted after blepharoplasty
and/or resurfacing, now can be treated with botulinum
toxin. The toxin is both safe and temporary. It
has now become a mainstream tool in cosmetic surgery.
TRENDS TOWARD COMBINATION
THERAPIES
Optimal improvement in appearance can more often
be obtained by combining procedures. At one end
of the therapeutic spectrum, topical medical therapy
utilizing agents like tretinoin, alpha-hydroxy
acids, hydroquinones and and 5-fluoruracil can
inhibit or referse ultraviolet-associated changes
in aging skin. At the other end of the therapeutic
spectrum, rhytidectomy, blepharoplasty, brow lift
and suction-assisted lipectomy often provide dramatic
results in facial rejuvenation. The choice of
therapy rests on the ability of the surgeon to
look at the face, analyze the antomic components
of the aging appearance, and then prioritize them,
mathcing procedure risk/benefit ratio to each.
Dr. Glogau is a dermatological surgeon practicing
in San Francisco. He is a clinical professor of
dermatology at UCSF, a member of SFMS and has
authored several texbooks and numerous articles
in the field of cosmetic dermatology and dermatologic
surgery. His current research interests are in
substances for soft-tissue augmentation, lasers
and the cosmetic uses of botulinum toxin, including
hyperhidrosis. As part of disclosure of potential
conflicts of interest, he wishes the reader to
know that he serves as a consultant to Allergan,
Inc., the manufacturers of BOTOX®.
|